Book Blogger Hop: How I Write My Reviews

This week’s question: What is your method for writing reviews – do you write immediately after reading, wait a few days, or write as you are reading? (submitted by Elizabeth @ Silver’s Reviews)

How I write my reviews

Writing book reviews, especially when I’m writing several a month can feel daunting. I’ve found a system for how I write book reviews that usually works for me. I create an outline then flesh it out.

Take notes

Each time I start a new book, I create a new note on my phone with the book’s:

  • Title
  • Author
  • Publisher
  • Pub date
  • Genre

Then as I read I keep notes about the basic plot, main characters, thoughts about the writing style and storyline.

Read other reviews

I always read other reviews about the book both professional/trade like Publisher’s Weekly and Book Pages as well as reviews on retail sites, Goodreads, NetGalley, and Edelweiss. Doing so gives me a different and wider perspective.

Likes and dislikes

Once I finish the book, I think about things like the plot, tone, voice, and characterization in the book. Did I like them or not.

Genre and tropes

I look at the genre and subgenre and think about the conventions of those types of books. Did the author meet my expectations? Like if it’s a mystery, does the reader find out who did it, and does it make sense within the confines of the story?

Then I make a list of the tropes in the book. Are they skillfully done? Did the other flip any on their heads like a meet-disaster instead of a meet-cute?

Putting it together

I sort through my notes, then write my review in Google Docs, fleshing out my outline. I include a summary, what I liked, and my rating based on five stars.

When I write the summary, I make sure that I don’t include spoilers.

Writing in Google Docs means I can easily copy and paste to Goodreads, retail sites, and my Bookstagram account.

Other things to add

  • I let readers know if the book is part of a series.
  • If possible, I suggest other authors or titles that readers might enjoy.
  • If necessary, I include content warnings.

In closing

I use an outline to structure my review, then flesh it out once I finish the book.

It’s not perfect but it usually works for me.

If I get stuck, this NoveList guide to genres usually sparks some inspiration.

Subscribe to my blog, Undine Reads, or follow my Bookstagram to get even more bookish content.

One Comment

  1. Anonymous said:

    Great post! I do write my reviews similar to how you do, except for reading other reviews. I read them after I post mine.?

    June 7, 2022

Tell me what you think!